Rae Hostetler

Media relations: prepare for the story

Rae Hostetler · Oct 8, 2025 ·

Our team has been supporting the Fluor staff that’s design building the new LP1 facility in Lebanon, Indiana, since 2023. Our scope of services includes all facets of public relations, internal, external, events, community relations and the list goes on.

Recently, company owner Rae Hostetler joined our client Fluor project community relations director Jeff Wagner for a local podcast. Host Joe LePage supports communications for the Town of Lebanon and lead our conversation. LISTEN HERE.

While many listeners probably don’t give a thought to the content, public relations professionals know it’s been discussed and determined in advance to ensure we stay on message. If you’re preparing for a similar interview (podcast, television, newspaper, radio), here are tips to ensure you’re ready. Media interview prep

Know your messages. What are the three to five messages that you want to be sure are included? Prepare. Write down talking points and think them through. Maybe even do a mock interview to be ready. A good reporter will ask questions and end an interview with, “What else do you have to add?” If your talking points were not totally covered this is your opportunity to share more information. And if that question isn’t asked, offer information before the interview is over. Just say, “Before we wrap up, can I add a few things?”

Remember the rules when working with a reporter. While an interviewer might seem friendly, often there are certain things that can and cannot be said based on the company, business or non-profit you represent. If a reporter asks a question you don’t want to answer, it’s easy to say, that’s interesting and divert to one of your key messages. Saying no comment sounds harsh. Know your messaging and use them well.

Know when the story will run and what it’s about. It’s your right to know what a reporter is writing about or producing. Just ask. Often reporters on deadline get in touch and ask a direct question because they need a source and they’re on deadline. They’re trying to get the story (fast) and can forget to give the big picture. It’s not on purpose. Just ask the story angle, who else is being interviewed and when it will appear.

And be sure to have fun sharing your story!

Why pitching a reporter is like making a sale

Rae Hostetler · Sep 20, 2025 ·

Indianapolis PR Company Public relations has several areas of practice. While the P in PR does not stand for press (it stands for public or audiences an organization needs to reach) reporters are often one group a client needs to reach to earn stories in the paper or on television news.

At the start of my professional career, I worked as a reporter. That experience has stayed with me for decades as my public relations career progressed. I’ve been inside a newsroom and part of the daily news cycle. I’ve heard from public relations professionals who were trying to place and share their stories on air. We call it being “pitched.”

If you’ve worked with a public relations professional, you’ve probably heard the term “pitch a reporter.” Easily defined, a pitch is about selling what’s newsworthy to get a reporter to write a story or create a package for the evening news. And yes, in the prior sentence I used the word selling strategically because placing a story is much like making a sale. Here’s why the two concepts are similar:

1) Build a credible relationship. Sales people know: cold calling is tough. The person on the other end of the email, call or text doesn’t know who you are or what you can offer. Once you meet with a company rep and build a relationship, earning and maintaining credibility is everything. Working with a reporter is similar. They’re all on deadline, have a certain need to fill and are moving quickly to build out the newscast. The daily news cycle is like a supply chain that must come together to deliver a final product. The key to building a credible relationship is getting a reporter what’s needed as soon as possible and keeping the process as easy as possible for them. And be sure the story you’re selling is really a news story.

2) Offer a quality product. Pitching a story means having a credible newsworthy angle. News stories aren’t about you, your product or service. A business professional once told me they weren’t happy with a local publication because the reporters wouldn’t write a story about him. I suggested he consider these questions: is your idea timely and trending to current information; is the idea you’re selling localized; is it a human interest story; is it relevant to appeal to the public?

3) Follow up. When a sales person is trying to get through the door to meet and greet a company representative, they follow up. Reporters expect the follow up. Many say they get too many emails. They see an idea and it moves down into the email box or it’s saved for later. A reminder: be sure to make the follow up professional.

4) Get the specs. When a customer places an order, there’s a process and most likely it includes questions on the specs before the order ships. If a reporter contacts you about the story pitch or another story, you get to ask questions to know the angle of the story and how you fit. For example, I’ve worked with reporters doing stories on national research and looking for a local comment. Knowing that information in advance and getting the research allows the client to think through their response before the interview.

5) Be ready when the order comes in. Given the current state of public health, many reporters have limited contact with the public. In “normal times” a reporter and/or photographer could show up at your door step to get what they needed for a story. Now they need photos, video and talking points supplied to them for the story. If you’re pitching the story, talking points and back up data should be at your fingertips and supplied to the reporter to use. And be ready. Today we had a successful story pitch. The reporter contacted us around 10 a.m. for a noon interview to build out a story for 5 p.m.

6) It’s ok to hear no. In sales, I’ve always been told to “beg for the no.” It keeps the pipeline filled with true prospects. The same applies to working with reporters. If they don’t want to do the story, that’s ok. There are others who do. Focus efforts on those professionals. I’ve heard stories from reporters about people who won’t accept the no. Refer back to number one above. When you have the credible relationship, it’s so much easier to make the pitch and close the sale not just today but for the next story idea that you have well into the future.

Build a public relations plan that stays the course

Rae Hostetler · Jan 15, 2025 ·

Public Relations Plan It happens regularly. A team is in the midst of executing a plan and suddenly someone walks through the door with a new idea. They read and article about a new trend. Sounds great. But it can feel deflating and even overwhelming to the professionals working on executing a public relations program.

Yes, public relations plans need to flex and change based on the current business environment. Yet jumping on trends without a solid understanding how the communications tool works can feel like adding one more thing to the to-do list instead of a strategic move.

Remain nimble/flexible with a plan
What is your public relations plan for the year? It’s important to have one in place and to continue moving forward. The plan will change if someone leaves the company and capacity gets tighter or your industry has a major announcement. There’s a difference between checking in and adapting and completely changing course. If a new communications trend falls into the mix, let the team talk it through to determine how it would strategically benefit the goals in the plan.

Keep it simple
A Forbes article from January ranks simple #1. I 110% agree. Simplicity is the essence of good taste. The essence of any public relations plan is keeping it simple, easy and manageable. The age of digital has created the perception that PR is a complex system that feels hard to navigate. It doesn’t have to be hard if you don’t want it that way. Bottom line, if everyone on the team doesn’t understand what you’re doing and why, then it might be time to step back and figure out why.

Set goals
What are three things you want to do this year and how will goals be accountable? I say three because I truly believe focusing well on a few initiatives at one time is the best way to succeed. Perhaps your website hasn’t been updated to work for your business in years. Think about the steps and time involved to make that right in a year’s time. Consider what you want that website to do for your business and how it will be measured (the goal).

Know your audience
Most business owners and leaders know their audience: internally employees, externally prospects, customers and so on. It’s critically important to think like your audience is thinking. If you’re running a global business, consider this. A McKinsey study shows people around the world have very different mindsets related to returning to “normal” activities. Here’s the contrast among those who reported, “I’m already doing them:”

81% in China
36% in America
18% in Mexico

Qualitatively speaking, during a recent local business meeting, a group was asked if they wanted to move Zoom meetings to in person. The trend is going back to the office, right? The business professionals preferred to stay online. They like the time earned back in their day. It is important to them.

Know the message
If your company doesn’t have a document that outlines the message, you should. We consider this document similar to logo colors and use. The message is part of your brand standard guidelines. Review it with this lens:

An Ernst & Young survey shows that 59% of surveyed consumers are more likely to shop locally in the long term. Is your business local or selling local goods? Should it be in the message?
A Consumer Index Report by Suzy Consumer Insights shares that 65% of consumers are more likely to support a brand that cares about the same social issues they do. What’s your community relations program and do you share it?

Know your tactics
Externally study after study shows it takes a person four to seven times to hear from you to recognize and remember your business. What are those four to seven tactics? Tactics include (but are not limited to) social media, media relations, business conferences, websites, SEO, PPC, speaking engagements and on and one. Think about how they could change in the future. For example, sending a mailer to a business several years ago when everyone was working at home didn’t make sense. Yet sending that mailer now might be a great idea.

Consider how the message gets communicated within the workplace or at home offices. Employees trust their managers. Are managers prepared to continue sharing critical company news as the year unfolds? Are they trained to deliver the message, and more importantly, do they know the message?

Share your public relations plan
Working quickly or without pulling in key team members sometimes means we inadvertently skip critical steps, including sharing information with or getting input from the right people. Remember to share your public relations plan with the professionals in your workplace who need to know. For example, public relations can impact the sales team generating leads. Does the director of sales know the plan and buy into it?

Public relations planning… by the numbers

Rae Hostetler · Nov 11, 2024 ·

We’ve had a lot of great conversations with business owners thinking about how to approach building a public relations and marketing program. Some have ideas and staff doing a great job working to execute. Others have ideas but no staff to do it. Still some don’t know where to start.

A common thread in these conversations are the questions we’re asked about a model for communications/marketing. I’d call it a best practice or rule of thumb that comes down to these numbers:

1) Have one plan. It can change. But work from one and just one as a team. Maybe you try something PR Planning that doesn’t work. Change the plan by removing it. We all get busy. If there’s a tactic you’d like to try but don’t have time this month, shift the idea. Keep the plan on paper and electronically for everyone to see/review and change.

3) Do three things well. Many times people come to the table to brainstorm ideas and the list gets long really fast. Review that list and think about three things your team can do—well. What will generate the most revenue and where can the team focus efforts. This is very strategic and should be the start of your plan.

5) Allocate budget. Rule of thumb is 5% of revenue (not net) should be allocated to marketing/communications. More if your company wants to grow. Budget for marketing/communications.

7) Be consistent. It takes 4 to 7 times for someone to hear and see your message for them to remember you and potentially take action. What feels like over communication is often just that—communicating your image.

Search Engine Optimization tips and tricks

Rae Hostetler · Oct 20, 2024 ·

Business owners and leaders often find themselves overseeing and/or managing the business website. Often what sounds like a complicated task, can be made simple by knowing the basics of Search Engine Optimization. Here and a few tips and tricks we’ve learned over the years by managing SEO for client websites.

Know your keywords
Similar to any business-related project, research is a good first step. What are the keywords Google searchers use to find your business, industry or non-profit? Put a list together and then use those keywords.

Feed Google and other engines content
Search engines use your website content to index pages. Feeding the right keywords and phrases is critical to being found. Google and other search engines are looking for keywords in a few places: the webpage title/tab, keyword (alt-tags) on photos/images on the pages, copy on the website pages and SEO programming in the website.

Blog, blog, blog
Adding blogs to the website gives search engines fresh content. It allows you to feed search engines those business critical keywords and phrases.

Refresh content
Update the photos on website pages, review page content to freshen keywords, double check key words continue to be relevant. Bottom line, websites are living, breathing marketing and communications tools for your business. It’s not about setting it and forgetting it. It’s about continuous improvement to make a website work for your business.

Consider Pay Per Click
Depending on your industry, sometimes competing for keywords to get you placed can be tough. Adding pay per click into the promotional mix can help to elevate your page placement. We’ve worked with clients who tried to DIY their pay per click, which is not a go-it-alone task. We recommend partnering with a professional to ensure the set up is correct from the start.